What the 12-Count Cookie Tin Actually Contains
The Milk Bar 12-Count Cookie Tin is a curated assortment built around the idea that one of each cookie isn't enough. Instead of a single sample, you get two of every cookie in the lineup, making it a practical choice for sharing, gifting, or just having a proper stash on hand. The tin includes two each of Compost, Cornflake Chocolate Chip Marshmallow, Confetti, Triple PB Cookie, Chocolate Chip N' Chunk, and Oatmeal Cream cookies.
Why Two of Each Matters
With a dozen cookies split evenly across six flavors, you don't have to fight over the last Compost Cookie or decide who gets the only Cornflake Chocolate Chip Marshmallow. The double-count format works well for couples, small households, or anyone who wants to taste each flavor twice. It also simplifies gifting: the recipient gets a full experience without needing to ration or choose favorites.
Cookie Tin Details from the Catalog
- Tin - 12 Count: This 12-count cookie tin has all the bases covered: chewy, crispy, fudgy, and salty-sweet, with two each of our Compost, Cornflake Chocolate Chip Marshmallow, Confetti, Triple PB Cookie, Chocolate Chip N' Chunk, and Oatmeal Cream cookies. The variety covers multiple texture and flavor profiles, so the tin appeals to different palates and works as a gift for someone whose preferences you don't know in detail.
Tin - 12 Count - Tin - 12 Count: Allergen Note: The Triple PB Cookie contains peanuts, but these cookies are individually wrapped for freshness and safety! Individual wrapping means you can separate the peanut-containing cookie from the rest, making it easier to serve at mixed-allergen gatherings or to keep as a personal treat.
Who This Tin Works Best For
The 12-count tin fits a sweet spot between a small sampler and a bulk order. It's large enough to feel like a proper gift or to stock a dessert table for a small party, but compact enough to ship nationwide without overwhelming the recipient. If you're ordering for a larger event or need more of a single flavor, you might prefer the single-flavor 12-count variants (Confetti, Oatmeal Cream, or Triple PB) instead of the assorted tin.
Trade-Offs to Keep in Mind
The assorted tin gives you variety, but at the cost of quantity per flavor. If you or your gift recipient already has a clear favorite, the single-flavor 12-count options might be more satisfying. Also, because the Triple PB cookie contains peanuts, the tin isn't suitable for nut-free environments unless you remove that cookie before serving. The individual wrappers help, but the tin itself is not segregated.
