Milk Bar: NYC's #1 Bakery Ships Desserts Nationwide

Greatest Hits Duo

Greatest Hits Duo - Main image
$87 In stock

Category: Gifts

If we believed in popularity contests, these fan favorites would win. The best-selling Birthday Cake and Assorted Cookie Tin are the perfect pair for any celebration! 

Customer Reviews (4.8 / 5 · 5 reviews)

Abigail ★★★★★

Gave this as a housewarming gift and both tins were gone by the end of the weekend. The birthday cake one is dangerously moreish, and the cookie assortment meant everyone got their favorite.

Lucy ★★★★★

The two-tin combo hits that sweet spot between variety and portion control—Birthday Cake for the nostalgic folks, the assorted cookies for everyone else. Opened the Cookie Tin first and it disappeared faster than the party napkins.

Aurora ★★★★★

Bought this for my sister’s birthday and the Birthday Cake tin alone was worth it—the frosting flavor is spot on, and the Assorted Cookie Tin gave us enough to snack on for a week. The pairing feels like two gifts in one, which made wrapping easy.