Milk Bar: NYC's #1 Bakery Ships Desserts Nationwide

Milk Bar® Pie

Milk Bar® Pie - Main image
Milk Bar® Pie - View 2Milk Bar® Pie - View 3Milk Bar® Pie - View 4
$53 In stock

Category: Pies

This cult classic put Milk Bar on the map. It has has a sticky, buttery, salty-sweet filling in a hearty oat-cookie crust. Ships nationwide and the perfect holiday gift. Get it delivered fresh, anywhere in the USA. We dare you not to have a second slice.

10” pie serves 8-10.

Before you pay

Check the method and total at checkout.

When it ships

Allow for processing time as well as the journey to you.

Standard Shipping: Handling (business days) 0–1; Transit (business days) 7–15.

Express Shipping: Handling (business days) 0–1; Transit (business days) 7–15.

View policy
If you need a refund

Keep your order number and contact the store to start.

Please contact us for the refund processing timeframe before returning an item.

View policy
Delivery costs

Review the cost for your destination and chosen service.

Standard Shipping · United States: $0.00

Express Shipping · United States: $3.99

View policy
Returning an item

Check the return conditions before sending anything back.

United States · Return window (days after delivery): 30. Return method: By mail. Return postage: Seller pays.

View policy

Customer Reviews (4.6 / 5 · 5 reviews)

Olivia ★★★★★

The oat-cookie crust held up surprisingly well even after a few days in the fridge—still hearty and not soggy at all. That sticky, buttery filling hits the salty-sweet spot perfectly, and it shipped fresh with zero damage. Already planning to order another one for the holidays.

Christopher ★★★★★

That filling is really something else—sticky, buttery, and that salty-sweet combo hits just right. The oat-cookie crust holds up beautifully even after a few days in the fridge, and it shipped without a scratch.

Kevin ★★★★★

The oat-cookie crust is the star here—hearty and sturdy enough to hold that sticky, buttery filling without getting soggy. I ordered it as a holiday gift for my sister and ended up grabbing another for myself; the salty-sweet balance is dangerously good.

Related Products