Milk Bar: NYC's #1 Bakery Ships Desserts Nationwide

Milk Bar Pie Slice

Milk Bar Pie Slice - Main image
Milk Bar Pie Slice - View 2
$7 In stock

Category: Loyalty Option

Enjoy a slice of the iconic Milk Bar Pie, a fan favorite from NYC's beloved bakery. This single slice delivers the signature buttery, salty-sweet flavor and gooey texture that has made Milk Bar famous, now available to ship nationwide.

  • Includes one (1) Milk Bar Pie Slice.
  • Features the classic, crave-worthy combination of buttery crust and rich, sticky filling.
  • Perfect for satisfying a sweet tooth or sharing a taste of New York.
  • Shipped fresh from Milk Bar, NYC's #1 bakery.

Customer Reviews (4.6 / 5 · 5 reviews)

Hazel F. ★★★★★

The gooey center held up perfectly after two days in the fridge, and that salty-sweet crust is pure magic with coffee. One slice somehow felt like just enough but left me craving another bite by evening.

David V. ★★★★★

I’m usually not one to order dessert online, but this slice held up shockingly well in transit — the gooey center was still intact and that buttery crust had just the right amount of crunch. Took a bite and immediately felt like I was back in a NYC bakery line.

Claire ★★★★★

The salty-sweet balance is spot on, and the gooey center held up perfectly even after a day in the fridge. One slice is genuinely enough to kill a craving, though I wish it came with a fork.