Milk Bar: NYC's #1 Bakery Ships Desserts Nationwide

Milk Bar Pie Slice

Milk Bar Pie Slice - Main image
Milk Bar Pie Slice - View 2
$7 In stock

Category: Loyalty Option

Enjoy a slice of the iconic Milk Bar Pie, a fan favorite from NYC's beloved bakery. This single slice delivers the signature buttery, salty-sweet flavor and gooey texture that has made Milk Bar famous, now available to ship nationwide.

  • Includes one (1) Milk Bar Pie Slice.
  • Features the classic, crave-worthy combination of buttery crust and rich, sticky filling.
  • Perfect for satisfying a sweet tooth or sharing a taste of New York.
  • Shipped fresh from Milk Bar, NYC's #1 bakery.
Before you pay

Check the method and total at checkout.

When it ships

Allow for processing time as well as the journey to you.

Standard Shipping: Handling (business days) 0–1; Transit (business days) 7–15.

Express Shipping: Handling (business days) 0–1; Transit (business days) 7–15.

View policy
If you need a refund

Keep your order number and contact the store to start.

Please contact us for the refund processing timeframe before returning an item.

View policy
Delivery costs

Review the cost for your destination and chosen service.

Standard Shipping · United States: $0.00

Express Shipping · United States: $3.99

View policy
Returning an item

Check the return conditions before sending anything back.

United States · Return window (days after delivery): 30. Return method: By mail. Return postage: Seller pays.

View policy

Customer Reviews (4.6 / 5 · 5 reviews)

Hazel F. ★★★★★

The gooey center held up perfectly after two days in the fridge, and that salty-sweet crust is pure magic with coffee. One slice somehow felt like just enough but left me craving another bite by evening.

David V. ★★★★★

I’m usually not one to order dessert online, but this slice held up shockingly well in transit — the gooey center was still intact and that buttery crust had just the right amount of crunch. Took a bite and immediately felt like I was back in a NYC bakery line.

Claire ★★★★★

The salty-sweet balance is spot on, and the gooey center held up perfectly even after a day in the fridge. One slice is genuinely enough to kill a craving, though I wish it came with a fork.