The Icons

Bought this for a friend’s birthday and ended up ordering a second one for myself—the built-in savings on getting both the Birthday Cake and the Milk Bar Pie together is the kind of math I can get behind. The pie’s texture was spot-on, and the rainbow flecks made the cake slice look like a party. Le

The rainbow-flecked Birthday Cake is as fun to look at as it is to eat, and the Milk Bar Pie's buttery crust is dangerously good. Having both in one order felt like a smart way to save a few bucks while covering dessert for every mood we were in.

Got both for a birthday gathering and the rainbow flecks in the cake made everyone smile before we even cut it. The pie's buttery crust held up perfectly even after sitting out for an hour.